I agree. You can not compare HOA fees unless the subdivisions are similiar.

FYI

The highest priced home currently listed for sale in the Southlands is $234,000.

Fox Field Farm $239,000
Sturbridge $204,000
Laurel Brook $578,000
Northbrook Manor $399,000
Autum Glen $499,000
Waters Lake $599,000
Bradshaw Farm $520,000
Newcastle Farms $479,000
Kingsgate $225,000

As you can see, you can throw out most of the examples given based on home value comparison. I don't know enough about the similiarly priced subdivisions to know if they match the Southlands in age, number of homes and ammenities available.